Audio stutter on car audio - bluetooth music

Hello,

Doesn’t matter if I use the mudita music player or any other 3rd party player or streaming app. Bluetooth audio has a big stutter issue.
The phone does not do this on headphones or speakers, only on the car audio. I tried in my and my wife’s car.

To make troubleshooting easier I’m going to give details on what is the situation and what I have tried;

  1. I’m using Mudita Kompakt on v1.6
  2. The car is a BMW 330e year 2020.
  3. The car has or had no bluetooth problems before, works perfectly fine with any other iPhone or Android phone, with or without CarPlay Android Auto.
  4. I tried the phone being charged or not charged as I was troubleshooting.
  5. I have disconnected, reconnected, forgot, re-pair the devices countless times.
  6. I killed every background app/task i can kill.
  7. I have reset the phone.
  8. I have reset the car infotainment system.
  9. I have tried downloaded music, I have tried streamed music.
  10. I have downloaded music from multiple streaming platforms with lowest quality.
  11. Services/apps i tried; native mudita music player, CalmMusic, one F-droid app that has been suggested here a lot but I truly forgot the name, spotify, youtube and apple. (I used all my “free for first month’s” and currently I’m sticking to AppleMusic as it has the least amount of audio stutters) Also yes I have disabled everything in these apps if they had any animations, canvas’ if they had it or showing lyrics. I made the apps as bare minimum as they can be.
  12. Bluetooth AVCRP I have tried 1.4 and 1.3, does not make a difference.
  13. Limited the maximum connected audio device to 1.
  14. Dropped the sample rate, codec, bits per sample to low or in connection favor.
  15. It gets better when; I start playing music, shut the bluetooth off, turn it on, connect with the car’s menu manually, music starts back automatically. This helps as the audio stutters become 1 - 2 per minute rather than 10 - 15 per minute.

All of these I did with of course restarting the phone and re-pairing the devices. This was one of the longest troubleshooting adventures I had in a long time. The car does not have a 3.5mm audio connection. I know I can get a usb-c to 3.5mm to use this but, I truly do not want another cable under my armrest. In my opinion, a bluetooth connection should work on a phone…

If anyone has any other idea on how to solve this issue, please let me know. I have long commutes and music helps. The audio stuttering as you are trying to listen is very annoying.

Note; I don’t know if this helps with anything, audio stutters on mostly low to mid range frequencies somehow, like a growly bass part or a low synth part in music triggers it more. (I don’t have magic ears but my guess is 200-300 kHz)

1 Like

I am using my Kompakt daily in my car. Connected via bluetooth and playing flac files from phone (local not streaming). No issues at all. Works perfectly every time.

Can You somehow, disable android auto in Your car? Just to make it stop trying to connect to phone via bluetooth? Just something I would try (if possible)

2 Likes

That’s a lot of troubleshooting you’ve done, maybe you did this already? Have you tried another bluetooth device with speakers and the Kompakt?

1 Like

yes Android Auto was disabled as I was trying to troubleshoot

1 Like

yes, my record player has a Bluetooth function and it works without this issue with that. Or any other small Bluetooth speakers or my sound bar. Only does this at the car.

2 Likes

Might help if the kompakt is plugged into usb power pack that is independent from the car power to prevent interference and ensure adequate power.

2 Likes

Tried your suggestion this morning, did not help.

2 Likes

If the kompakt bluetooth works in a different car that would be interesting to know. I think then it may be electronic interference in the BMW.

1 Like

This is an odd case situation. I would recommend that you reach out to our customer service for specific technical support. They will probably need to request your logs to see what happened behind the scenes for this to occur. They can be reached via email at [email protected] or, alternatively, you can submit a support request/support ticket directly on our website:

Additionally, a video/audio of the problem would most likely help our customer service team hear the problem.

1 Like

thank you, I’ve reached out to them. I tried to include the video here as well but I don’t think videos are allowed to be uploaded here. So I uploaded it as unlisted in youtube.

1 Like

@mertgndz Thank you! I will make sure it reaches them.

I’m having essentially the same issue with my car (2026 BMW M2). The music app doesn’t seem to play at all through bluetooth. Audio plays through spotify but cuts in and out every second or two.

Was there any solution to this?

2 Likes

Hello and welcome to the forum.
First of all, sick car, congratulations!

I solved the problem, but it might not be what you are looking for. Before you do;
I have reached out to the support team and they wanted me to send a bug report, which I did. After their investigation the problem was “BMW iDrive being too demanding”. After that they gave me some suggestions on what might help, which didn’t change anything. They promised that they will return back to this issue but they can’t promise when, and since I opened the ticket dated when @urszula commented, nothing came back. So there is no proper solution to this on MuditaOS K. Possible solution would have been an AUX cable but BMW’s do not offer them anymore and a USB C to AUX cable will not work as well before you spend money on it.

My solution was to install Kompakt OS by our dear @gezimos . You can read about it on the forum here; Unofficial LineageOS 23.2 - Android 16 for Kompakt
After switching to KompaktOS, audio stutter simply didn’t happen. Might be the case MuditaOS K being Android 12 and KompaktOS being Android 16, or better optimization or who knows, it doesn’t do it.
I would say try to use the phone as is and if it is giving you too much problems on your day to day use maybe consider KompaktOS for this specific reason. As this was the only thing that solved the issue for me.

Hope I could help.

1 Like

I believe the user reached out to our customer service and they did some troubleshooting.
It might be worth opening a support ticket and they could go through your options:

They could request some logs, but they will guide you through that process.

Thanks so much!

Makes sense, I reached out to support as well and will try it again in the morning after updating my phone (didn’t realize I was on an old version). If not, I think I’ll have to go with your solution for now.

1 Like