Music app updates after OS K 1.4

First up, a quick overall positive review before more details on requests: I’ve had my Kompakt for a few weeks now. Just got the 1.4 update which was very important in making it feel like a functional device. Overall, I replaced my iphone with the Kompakt to eliminate the feeling of always wanting to check my phone and it has been very successful at that. I no longer just pull my phone out of my pocket just because I am not actively doing something else and I really appreciate that.

The music app is the most important app beyond phone/sms for me. The music app pre 1.4 was pretty hard to use when full. I’ve loaded about 1400 songs on it so far and have many more to add. I pretty much just had to shuffle all of them. Even making playlists on the device without any organization system was tedious and I only made a couple short ones.

The 1.4 update is definitely a huge improvement. I’d say it took the app from too frustrating to use much to essentially functional.

I hope we can continue getting some more updates though. Three requests quickly jump out to me. First, I have my music organized in folders in a standard Artist (folder) / Album (folder) / Song (file) structure and I really wish the Kompact displayed/played songs in track order instead of alphabetical order. Standard formatting across all the sources I pulled music from seems to be that the track number is prepended to the file name. So even if the folder was just sorted by file name instead of alphabetical song name that would work better.

Second, I wish there was a way to make a playlist on my computer then sync it to the Kompakt. It’s still tedious to search through all my music on the device and build a playlist. It would be much easier to do it on a computer and then just have it sync. I’m not sure how the playlists work on the backend, but I imagine its something simple like a text file with a list of file names to include. Even if we could just edit those files in Mudita Center, that would be easier.

Third, I wish there was a way to push songs to playlists from the song interface. I imagine this could look like a button on the play screen that currently shows album name, a giant music note image, song name, artist name, a playback tracker bar, and playback controls that allows you to add it to a playlist.

Finally, a tip for others - I find it vastly easier to do data transfer via the microSD card than by plugging the Kompakt into a computer and using the Mudita Center. I pop the sd card out of the phone, pop it in my computer, and use the stand file editor on my computer. The file transfer is 90% faster and its a lot easier to move, edit, and organize files. When I put it back in the Kompakt, it loads up reasonably quickly and performs the same way on the front end. Importantly, I can just drag and drop my entire music collection and my computer figures out which files are duplicates and only keeps one copy, unlike the Mudita Center uploader. Music management has gotten much easier since I figured this out.

I’d also love to hear others’ tips, tricks, and requests for the music app! Thanks!

8 Likes

+1 for adding music to the playlist from the playback interface. I rarely sit and build a playlist; I add songs as I’m listening and notice something I want to add.

1 Like

Are you looking for this to be done wirelessly? Or when you connect to Mudita Center? How do you envision this feature working?

I wish there was a way to push songs to playlists from the song interface.

Can you elaborate a bit more? I’m having a hard time visualizing this.

Otherwise, thank you so much for the feedback. I will pass it on to the team

Thanks for the thorough review. I didn’t realize you can use a microSD card with Mudita Kompakt — how do you plug it in?

1 Like

You just put it into the slot where the sim cards go

I imagine the easiest would be to do it in Mudita Center. The way I would design it would be to set up the structure in Mudita Center as:
Manage Files (Left Bar)
-Phone Storage (Left Bar)
–Music (Middle Bar)
—Folders (Middle Bar)
----MusicFolder1 (Middle Bar)
-----SongFile1 (Left Bar)
-----SonFile_n (Left Bar)
----MusicFolder2 (Middle Bar)
—Playlists (Middle Bar)
----Playlist1 (Middle bar)
----Playlist2 (Middle bar)
----Playlist_n (Middle bar)
–Photos (Middle bar)
–E-books (Middle bar)
–App Installers (Middle bar)
-SD Card (Left bar)

Then you could drag and drop songs from the right bar into the playlists named in the middle bar).

I think adding songs from the play screen to a playlist would be really simple. I would just add a “+” button on the play screen something like this (see my addition in blue):


I think the button could go up top where I put it or added to the bottom row of buttons. When you click it, it would bring up a little dialog that says something like:

Add to Playlist
–Playlist 1
–Playlist 2
–Playlist 3
Cancel
Then you just click on one of your playlists, it adds it, and then the dialog closes.

2 Likes

I would add “Create new playlist” to your “Add to Playlist” dialog.

1 Like

I also really hope that the player will be revised again in the next update and that the tracks in the folders will be displayed in the correct order, i.e. by track number and not alphabetically, so that I can listen to the songs from the corresponding albums in the correct order.

3 Likes

@marko I replied in another thread that further music player updates are planned for 2026, however, as per the Mudita Kompakt Roadmap, I don’t have the specifics. I’ll ask the team when they come back from holiday break if they can share any specifics.

Has there been any feedback yet?

1 Like

@marko Unfortunately I don’t have any specifics yet. I will ask again.

Hi ! I’ve just received my Kompakt ! Love it so far.
However, when browsing the folders in the built-in music player, even though the files are named properly (prefixed by the track number), it gives the feeling they are played in random order.

I mean it neither respects the filenames / alphabetical order (which was what I needed) nor the track number in the ID3 tags.

Any idea ?

Edit : OUCH ! They are played alphabetically… But based on the track name, and not the file name :-/ Which is never the correct order actually !

2 Likes

@bidinou Our team is planning some music player improvements for future updates

2 Likes

Thanks ! Wonder if the users have some tips to share on how to use it in the current state ? (apart from playing random tracks or creating playlists :wink:

1 Like

It’s been said before on the forum, but I just side launched Gramophone and it keeps everything in order just like an mp3 player would. It does mean the music widget on the lock screen can’t be used though (unless you install some other os).

I’d really love using the native music app instead, but I’ll wait until the issue with the track numbers is fixed. I’m sure it must be in the pipeline.

1 Like

Just chiming in to say that @davidray has started work on an excellent music app that solves a lot of issues with the current stock app.
Beta version at GitHub - davidraywilson/CalmMusic: A minimal mindful music app built to work on de-googled E-ink devices utilizing the Mudita Mindful Design library.

5 Likes

This is awesome, but am I right in assuming there’s no APK to install? Rather, I’d have to know what I’m doing if I’d like to try it out?

Edit: sorry, my bad. Not very used to Github, found it!

2 Likes

I’ve been there! It’s such a confusing site sometimes

2 Likes

@bidinou One of the things I do is create folders on my computer & organize the files that way.

1 Like

Hi ! Well, that is already the case. My files have been organized the same way for almost 30 years :wink:

Genre/Artiste - Album/Track Number - Track Name.mp3/flac

The issue is that, the files are still sorted by Track Name in the player, thus ignoring the track number.
I would have to change the ID3 tags to include the Track Number in the Track Name :wink:

I will wait for the update !

1 Like