Messaging review by wander

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

thank you! I successfully imported my message history now. I did notice another possible bug: someone sent an ‘album’ of 4 photos in a signal group, but only the first one was shown in the Messaging app. Also, when I open a photo, I will always be asked which app I want to use to view the picture.

Finally: when I’m typing a message, I don’t see a cursor. I am using FUTO keyboard.

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★☆

Second the part where I do not see a cursor. Furthermore, if I keep Signal/SMS separate, I do not see the indicator for an unread message (name is in bold and there is a cirlce next to it)

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

@superannette — thank you, all three were real. The other photos in an album were saved all along; the app only ever drew the first. They now show two across, and each opens or saves on its own. Opening a photo no longer asks every time: your phone asks once and can remember. And there’s a cursor now as soon as you tap into the message box. It wasn’t FUTO: the app hid the cursor on purpose, then failed to bring it back. All in v1.23.1.

@nico.n — the cursor is fixed in v1.23.1, same cause as above. You were right about the unread marker too: the separate Signal list had its own row that never showed unread at all. It now has the dot and the bold preview, as the combined list does.

2 Likes

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Amazing! It all works now :partying_face:

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

Have you had a chance to check it out?

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Hi wander,
I found another bug: I archived a few Signal conversations, and want to unarchive them but it doesn’t ‘stick’. The next time I open the app, they are all back in the archived folder.

I also have two requests, feel free to ignore them :wink:

  1. In the signal app, I can reply to a specific message and which then shows up as a ‘quote’ in my message. Clicking the quote will lead you to the original message that the new message is in reply to. I would love for this function to exist in the Messaging app.
  2. I would love it if gifs would show up inside the chat conversation. Now I can only see a file name and when I click it, the gif will play and then close after one loop.

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★☆☆

I have Signal running on a.n.other Android device. MY account has a password/pin. I was unable to transfer my account to the Kompakt. Wonder what I did wrong?

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

@superannette — the unarchive was a real bug, and it’s fixed in v1.24.0. Each time the app opened, it read your Signal account’s settings and applied every conversation’s “archived” again, even ones nothing had changed about. It now does what Signal does and only takes a change the account has actually made, so a chat you unarchive stays unarchived. One limit: the unarchive stays on this phone. Your other Signal devices still have those chats archived until you unarchive them there too.

GIFs now show in the conversation as their first frame, with :play_button: GIF underneath. A tap plays it once where it is, then it goes back to that first frame. They don’t loop or play by themselves, because every frame is a full redraw on this screen. GIFs you received before this update were saved without the mark that says they’re GIFs, so they’ll show a still frame but still open in another app. New ones will play in the conversation.

Quoted replies are in v1.25.0. Long-press a message and choose Reply, and the reply arrives in Signal as a quote. Tapping a quote above a message takes you to the one it answers.

@anon89409232 — Messaging doesn’t take a Signal account over from another phone. It joins your account as a linked device, the same way Signal Desktop does, and your other phone stays in charge of the account. Your PIN isn’t needed for that, because a link happens on the phone that already has Signal.

On the Kompakt, go to Settings → Signal → Link this phone. It shows a code. On the phone with Signal, open Settings → Linked devices → Link new device, and scan it. Keep the Kompakt on that screen until it says it’s linked, since the code expires after about a minute and a half. Conversations start from that moment. Signal doesn’t send a new device your old history, and importing a Signal Desktop export is how to bring it over.

If you tried “Register this number” instead, that’s the likely snag. It makes the Kompakt the account itself, and an account with a PIN usually has registration lock on, which Messaging can’t use yet. In that case it says “This number has a registration lock” and suggests linking instead.

If linking doesn’t work either, tell me which step it stops at and what it says there.

1 Like

Review updated by @wander

  • Version: 1.12.0 → 1.24.0
  • Description updated
  • Checksum: ff121b4876d8f104605b3309ef6b647572b7a7f5c6f70ef5211d507ea116562d → 2f432eac30b1ae739108964fe478222ab1515c6ff200a7e83845fa1b1e17c38a

View current review

Review updated by @wander

  • Version: 1.24.0 → 1.26.0
  • Description updated
  • Checksum: 2f432eac30b1ae739108964fe478222ab1515c6ff200a7e83845fa1b1e17c38a → f3b131cbb6369fdad42309bd62b0ff1a37f643c37441a422993ca2fac80abf2b

View current review

Review updated by @wander

  • Version: 1.26.0 → 1.26.1
  • Checksum: f3b131cbb6369fdad42309bd62b0ff1a37f643c37441a422993ca2fac80abf2b → 7d36b915158dd7aac58aa8f7644f2b88415f7fd5a5c535f069992353de4a608c

View current review

Review for version 1.26.1
User rating: ★★★★☆

Iterating so fast wow!

@wander I asked a question earlier about the background activities work. Can i close the app, and still get notifications or does Signal only catch up when I open it? Should I disable Duraspeed?

1 Like

Review for version 1.26.1
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

edit: @nicolas.niegsch — a correction to my last answer. With the app closed, Signal still checks in by itself about every 15 minutes, and a little less often while the phone is asleep. It doesn’t wait for you to open it.

For messages as they arrive, turn on Settings → Signal → Keep Signal connected. It holds the connection open, at the cost of a permanent notification.

Either way, DuraSpeed on the Kompakt can close the app in the background and stop both. Allowing Messaging in DuraSpeed keeps them running, so you don’t need to turn DuraSpeed off completely.

1 Like

Review for version 1.26.1
User rating: ★★★☆☆

Hunm. Linking account means I still need another phone on and connected to the internet? As in if I made the Kompakt my only device, I could not connect ot Signal directly from your app?

Review for version 1.26.1
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

@anon89409232 — no to both.

Linked, the other phone doesn’t need to be on or online. Signal delivers to each device separately, the way Signal Desktop keeps working with your phone switched off. What the other phone has to do is stay the account: if Signal is set up again on it, or the number is registered somewhere else, the Kompakt’s link ends.

And the Kompakt can be your only Signal. Settings → Signal → Register this number makes it the account for your number, with no other phone at all. You need the number to receive a text or a call with the code. Signal on the old phone stops working, and so does anything else linked to the account, such as Signal Desktop. Your old messages stay on the old phone, but you can bring them across by importing a Signal Desktop export.

As of v1.27.0 your PIN is no longer a snag. If the account has registration lock on, Messaging asks for the PIN, and your contacts and settings come across with the number. Take care with it: after too many wrong tries Signal deletes the PIN’s data and the number stays locked for a while.

Review updated by @wander

  • Version: 1.26.1 → 1.27.0
  • Checksum: 7d36b915158dd7aac58aa8f7644f2b88415f7fd5a5c535f069992353de4a608c → 697c68bb038c2fbf6484da1d7c7cd19555467c5c7a7f84c80124b420bc10b0f1

View current review

Review updated by @wander

  • Version: 1.27.0 → 1.27.1
  • Checksum: 697c68bb038c2fbf6484da1d7c7cd19555467c5c7a7f84c80124b420bc10b0f1 → d43916be51b010e948019d6bee5da67ce8b187ca9a1fa248b00317133a6719fc

View current review

Review for version 1.27.1
User rating: ★★★★☆

Issue: When scrolling through messages, some messages ‘get lost in the scroll’. So I scroll upwards to older messages, then scroll down again and I find 2 messages that I previously could not see.

1 Like

Review updated by @wander

  • Version: 1.27.1 → 1.27.4
  • Checksum: d43916be51b010e948019d6bee5da67ce8b187ca9a1fa248b00317133a6719fc → 1ebf3994708b397d1ceaa5dc0431d27559071b9807c012c717c068aa43c947cd

View current review

Review for version 1.27.4
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

Thanks for this. It was a real bug, and it’s fixed in v1.27.4.

Messaging turns a page at a time rather than scrolling freely, so the screen doesn’t smear. When a page moved back towards older messages, it tidied the top of the screen by moving up a little further. That pushed the message at the bottom out of sight before you’d seen it. Going down never did this, which is why the missing messages turned up on the way back.

Now each page back ends on the message the previous page started with, so there’s always one message of overlap and nothing is skipped.

1 Like