Messaging review by wander

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

yes I understand the meta hatred, I share it to be honest. But no one uses SMS or anything else here, there was a time that I’d try to reach people via SMS but most people completely stopped checking them. When I talk to people about this they say they have like 10+ unread sms because only authentication SMS’ are relevant there and they don’t need to check it as Iphones just put the code on the clipboard as you receive them. So whatsapp is incredibly deeply rooted in the society (even in the government) here.

I’ll try to somehow do something like this myself. I stopped software development 5-10 years ago and to be honest have no experience in mobile nor Kotlin. So it will be a big challenge. (especially time as I stopped spending time behind my computer)
I don’t use AI so vibe coding is not an option but maybe this can be done via notification listener. (doubt sending or receiving media will work that way)
Or use it as a companion device as whatsapp allows it. I don’t know I can communicate the 2 apps with android API or if you would receive notifications because of Duraspeed even if it works.

So I see your point being that this seems like a great amount of work.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★☆

Thank you for that app! I have been looking for an e-ink Signal client.

I have a question about the way Signal messages come and leave. When I opened the app, it told me “not connected to Signal” and I could not write back in the chat. How does that work?

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Heya! I’m interested in the Signal functionality but I can’t figure out how to connect it when Signal is already on my Kompakt! I obviously can’t scan a QR code on my own phone screen, but the other option says it’s for “first time Signal,” and it’s not my first time, I’ve been using Signal on the Kompakt for a while. Please tell me there’s an option besides taking out my SIM card and getting Signal set up on a whole other phone, I really don’t want to restart the 30 days of RCS removal.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Great app, thanks so much!
Question: after linking Signal, the app shows an option ‘Bring history in’ from a desktop export. I exported my messages from the Signal desktop client, copied the whole folder onto my Kompakt and pointed this option to that folder. However, nothing happens. Am I doing something wrong? Thank you in advance!

Edit: another thing I just noticed is that in a group conversation on Signal, someone’s name doesn’t show up with their message, just a seemingly random number. In the same group, another participant’s name does show up correctly.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★☆

This is an E Ink-friendly variation of QUIK, but I miss the character counter that QUIK has, so I give this app four stars instead of five.

I can text-message via SMS between here in the USA and a friend in Europe, but I must keep my messages to 140 characters or fewer. QUIK tells me when I start to approach – or have gone past – the 140-character limit for each SMS message.

Yes, maybe I can have a messaging app split my longer messages into multiple messages of 140 characters or fewer, but I appreciate the discipline that staying within that 140-character limit imposes upon my messages! The character counter in QUIK helps me to write better messages, as does the character counter in InkMessage.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

@nico.n
The phone holds its own connection to Signal, as a linked device does. Receiving survives a gap — messages wait on Signal’s servers and arrive when the socket is back — but sending cannot happen without it, so the composer refuses rather than taking a message that would quietly never go.
What you hit is a fault in how that was said, though. Every launch begins disconnected for a second or two while the socket reaches for the server, and the line you saw made no distinction between that and a connection that is not coming back. So a phone that was about to work told you it was broken. Version 1.20.13, out now, says “Connecting to Signal” while it is reaching, and keeps the blunter line for when it genuinely cannot.
If it ever stays on the blunt one, the thing to check is battery handling — the Kompakt ships with Duraspeed, and anything that stops the app running in the background takes the connection with it. Tell me what the Signal section of Settings says and I will dig in.
Thanks for asking; “why does it say that” turned out to be the right question.

@TechVampire
You are right that there was no way in, and right to refuse the other one — registering the number afresh deregisters Signal wherever else it is, and on the Kompakt that means starting the thirty days over. Don’t do that.
The obstacle is optical rather than anything else: linking is one Signal reading another’s code with a camera, and a phone cannot photograph its own panel. So version 1.20.13, out now, puts the code somewhere your phone’s camera can see it — the page this app already serves to your own computer. Open Link this phone as usual, and if Desktop Sync is on, the screen gives you an address. Open that on your computer, and point this phone’s Signal at the monitor: Settings → Linked devices → Link new device.
No second phone, no SIM moved, nothing about your account changed. The code is only on that page while the link screen is open, and it is behind the same token as the rest of Desktop Sync.
Thanks for reporting it clearly. It was a real gap, and the fix is better than what I first tried.

@superannette
Two separate things, and you found a real bug with the second one.
The name: in a group, a person was named from your address book, or from your one-to-one conversation with them if you had one — and if neither existed it fell through to their number. Which is exactly why one person in your group read correctly and another didn’t. Signal knows that person’s name; the app simply never asked for it. Fixed in version 1.20.13, which is out now.
The import, I can’t explain yet, and I would rather say so than guess. What I can say is that it should never have stayed silent: if reading the export failed, it was telling you the folder was wrong, and if it finished while the screen was away, it said nothing at all. Both are fixed. Now that version 1.20.13 is out, please try again — it will tell you what actually happened, and that will be the thing I can fix.
One thing worth checking meanwhile: the folder to choose is the one that directly holds main.jsonl. If you copied a folder across, that may be the folder inside the one you picked.

@kirkmahoneyphd
Your instinct is right: on a route between countries, holding to one message is sound. It is the split into parts that goes wrong out there, not the length.
But 140 is not a character limit. It is the byte limit, and plain SMS text packs eight characters into seven bytes — so one message is 160 characters, not 140.
The part that will actually be biting you: that limit is not fixed. One character outside the plain SMS alphabet re-encodes the whole message, and then a part holds 70 characters rather than 160. A curly apostrophe counts. So does an accent, a dash, an emoji. Most keyboards turn a typed ’ into a curly one by themselves, so this happens without anything on screen saying so — and your careful 140 becomes three parts on a route where parts are what fails.
Two things. Settings has “Strip accents from outgoing SMS”, which keeps you on the plain alphabet and the limit at 160 whatever your keyboard inserts. And version 1.20.13, out now, says it out loud: when a draft has re-encoded, a line above the composer tells you the limit just became 70, and the counter starts counting from the first character instead of waiting until you are nearly out.
The counter was never removed, for what it’s worth — it is QUIK’s, unchanged. It just had nothing useful to say at 140 of 160. Thank you for the report; it found a real gap.

3 Likes

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Thank you, @wander! You are an excellent teacher!

I installed version 1.20.13 (Thank you for the prompt update!) and confirmed that I could enter 160 7-bit (plain-text) characters and thereby reach “0” on the countdown tally, which started its countdown at “10” when I had entered the first 150 7-bit (plain-text) characters.

I have updated my rating from four stars to five, and I took your advice to enable Settings > Sending > Strip accents from outgoing SMS. Thanks again, @wander!

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Got it set up and it seems to be working great! Thank you so much, as a big Signal user it’s great to finally be using an eink optimized app for it. Also means I can free up another app slot on my Katapult homepage. Thanks so much for the quick fix and the awesome app!

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

I am using the app for a while now and it works great!

One request: will you add the possibility to send and listen to voice messages? I am using that function a lot and its the only reason at the moment for me to keep a seperate Signal app on my phone.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★☆

Thank you for the update! In the meantime, I found another slight problem. How does the app handle attachments in Signal? For example, I can se pictures, but only very small and I can’t do anything with them (like download them). Other files, like epub (fast way to to get a file to Kompakt) I can’t download.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Thank you so much for your reply! I’ll install the new version tonight and try again!

The import problem might have been caused by using the wrong folder, but I don’t remember (and I already deleted the import folder on my Kompakt). But now I know how it works I can at least make sure I’m pointing it to the right folder.

Edit: both issues are resolved for me now! Thanks again!

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

I have this problem too

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

1.21.0 is up.

Voice messages, both directions — a microphone beside the attach button in a Signal conversation. Tap to start, tap again to stop; it waits in the composer until you send it. Ones that arrive play with a tap. @hanswilli, this was your ask.

Attachments. Tap a picture to open it full size; anything else has Open and Save a copy… under a long press, so an epub can land where your reader will find it. Pictures in a thread are drawn at a proper size now. @nico.n, @superannette — this was yours.

@superannette, on the import: the folder to choose is the one that holds main.jsonl.

3 Likes

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

Wow, thank you so much for the quick implementation of voice messages!!!

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★☆

Thank you so much! It is incredible what you are doing.

I found another ‘bug’? I will get constant messages about the usernames people chose. Every day, I wll get a note from everyone that person X (like they are called in my phone) is now called Y (their username) I think in Sign this should only happen once, but I get it at least once a day.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

Fixed it. Update to the latest release. Thanks again for your help!

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★☆

Could you please explain how the syncing and getting new messages work? Do I need to exempt the app from Duraspeed to work properly?

And if I keep “Keep Signal connected” off, how does it get new messages and how often is that checked? I don’t really understand if it works in the background or if it only gets new messages once I open the app.

Second, there is an option to keep Signal and SMS in separate groups.

Would it be possible to change the default groups (on top of the screen when you open the app) to SMS / Signal / Groups or something like that? Right now, the distinction between All/Groups/Unknown does not make a lot of sense to me. For me personally, this app would serve as a replacement for Signal/Molly. But it would make sense, if I keep SMS/Signal separate, that when I open the app, it would show me my Signal messages first (or my SMS messages first, whatever the preference is)

Otherwise, stoked to try it out on my main phone! Will keep you updated about other “problems”.

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

Get the latest release – I’ve added this feature under the Signal settings menu when the separate lists view is toggled. Thanks for your help!

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
User rating: ★★★★★

app looks great!

Any plan to support zerotier VPN in addition to tailscale?

1 Like

Review for version 1.12.0
Author’s rating: ★★★★★ · Author of this review

I’ve opened it up so you can use Zerotier, Tailscale, or another VPN of your choice.

1 Like