Community Apps is a mess

Increasingly, it seems like 90% of the apps in Community Apps is being vibe-coded by one individual. Is there a way that we can have this user’s apps in a thread created just for them? Genuinely cannot find an app, especially a non vibe-coded app, created by someone else there because this user keeps posting a new app daily.

Can we just create an individual thread for people who make more than one app? Otherwise, Community Apps is difficult to navigate and increasingly seems pointless.

Also, why do people have to rate their own apps before posting their app?? What person would not give their own app five stars? Also, why does every single reply/question about an app in an app thread in Community Apps require a rating? It makes no sense, especially when someone just wants to ask a question or has yet to even try the app.

8 Likes

me when lightsaber

4 Likes

I like the selections.
Utilities are there. Tools, as separate app category perhaps?

1 Like

Wholeheartedly agree. Thanks for naming this in. :folded_hands:

I have had mixed feelings about it since I have really gotten rolling over the last month making and sharing apps here on the forum. I experimented early on with not updating the Community Apps threads when I made updates to the apps themselves, hoping to just post once and then nudge people towards Obtanium; but then the checksum would fall out of line and I’d get notified saying as much. Since then I’ve just leaned into updating each time.

I feel hesitant to engage with the Community Apps setup as it is, especially when updating a lot of apps at once, because I know it’s going to flood the forum. I never want to drown out other creators in this community or make it difficult to find other offerings.

And… I have come to understand that many users don’t go to Github or use Obtanium, and so the forum threads getting updated is the way they currently receive their important 3rd-party app updates. Until there is another way of sorting or arranging the Community Apps forum, I will continue to stay compliant and update my apps as changes and improvements are made to them.

I also agree completely with the developer not having to rate their own apps (why would I do less than 5 stars? :peacock:), and thread replies not needing to rate the app in order to post in the thread so that people could ask clarifying questions about the app before they have to dive in. Those are both awkward and unhelpful on my end of things too, FWIW.

I understand that inkApps is coming with 2.0 in November. I imagine that will address these issues entirely, recreating an F-Droid/CalmApps sort of experience regarding App updates and postings. And without a doubt, I may have been the extreme case that has challenged what would have otherwise been a fine system – sorry, not sorry? It’s the same way with my apps really: I make them out of personal curiosity and interest in supporting others, I think they are solid, and then they get into the hands of all of you, with your various use cases, and I get to receive feedback and improve them beyond my own vision for the benefit of all.

I trust Mudita is here for the same mission and that the Kompakt is offered in this same spirit: a heartfelt passion project shared with a community that will naturally expose it’s flaws (because every project has them) and get remedied for a richer result. Of course, they will stick to their aesthetic and functional vision of it in some regards, but Mudita has been really open from the start about sharing resources (MMD, @urszula 's constant presence here :heart:, user surveys) and being open to other’s contributions (this rather honest forum, inkApps, sideloading, selling phones, etc). I also know they are a small company, and unlike me, perhaps have lives :sweat_smile:, but I believe they are deeply interested in their project succeeding, and the community that co-dreams with them to support it.

Again, thank you for naming this. I didn’t quite have the will to, but I felt it also. I’m open to take any suggestions you have for how to proceed in the meantime, while honoring the need to share updates. I’m also open to any app feedback or ideas you have – I seem to have an abundance of free time :melting_face:

11 Likes

I also have a few complaints about the Community apps.

  1. The order of elements is neck-breaking. Not a single app starts on the same order. All depend on the category/dev/mmd icon.

  2. Icon should go first, then the title of the app/review. The stuff like category/dev/mmd should go under the title as a 2nd row.

  3. Rating makes no sense. An app with a single rating is higher than my app that has 48 ratings. My app Katapult has 5.0 rating at 48 reviews, and if it it’s placed around ~50th position.

  4. I agree with both op and @wander that “dev” shouldn’t have to rate their app.

  5. Reviews for apps and listings for community apps should be at least in separate tabs.

10 Likes

Thanks, everyone, for sharing your feedback and suggesting ways to improve this section.

You raise valid concerns about the section. Over the last few weeks the section has really grown & we need to accomodate for that. People should also be able to ask questions without having to rate an app they haven’t tried yet.

I’ll discuss these issues and your suggestions with the team so we can look at how to make Community Apps easier to browse & use.

Thank you also to everyone creating, sharing, testing, and updating apps here.
We REALLY want this space to work well for both contributors and the people discovering their work.

6 Likes

I do agree with you, after you mentioned this I began to realize that @wander apps are all made with AI. None of them have a congruency and there are constant updates and patches because AI does not truly understand the human experience with an app. The point of this phone is intentionality and thoughtfulness, which is the exact opposite of what a robot doing everything for you is.

1 Like

I hear your perspective. To be clear, I do use AI to help write the code, and I check it all on my own phone before it goes out. Inevitably I miss things – my use case doesn’t cover every feature, so I can be blind to it. Fortunately I have a good community here to help :heart_hands:

I do think the apps I share are rather congruent. It’s something I personally value, and I’ve made every effort to bring them into line with the MMD guide. The constant updates come from the reports people post here, plus my own tinkering, which is the part I like most. Getting an update out as soon as it’s in was a choice I made early on (because apparently if you’re too slow that draws complaints too :melting_face:).

If one of the apps isn’t working for you, just name it and I’ll see what I can do. If none are for you, that’s fine too. But I think you’re underestimating how much thought, time and effort goes into these, and that feels unfair. (And if you think I’m the only one around here using AI, I have a llama to sell you.)

7 Likes

I apologize if I came across as rude. I have a hard stance against AI, I believe we are allowing these large companies to force their investments down our throats, and we are becoming complacent.

I think people are forgetting to ask why. Why am I letting this into my everyday life? Why can’t I just attain the skills I am asking it to do for me? Why can’t I just use my own brain and problem solve.

We are losing what makes us most human and I just want to try and stop it before it becomes too late.

4 Likes

Hi, if you don’t mind, I would like some clarity.

When you “check it out on your own phone,” does that include looking through the code itself to ensure there isn’t some massive security issue in it?

I am also pretty anti-AI, but I can believe it can generate usable code… if a human with the necessary skills is checking the work. And I don’t just mean running the program on the user end to see if the features work, I mean looking at the code itself to make sure it’s not doing something undesirable or just unnecessary on the back end. I work in information science and I’m very familiar with how easily AI will warp or outright fabricate textual information, I am not convinced it doesn’t do the exact same thing when generating code.

3 Likes

@claytonevandavis thank you for saying that. I understand where you’re coming from, and I won’t try to talk you out of it. FWIW, I’m running a local LLM on my home server – I don’t feel anything is going down my throat or making me complacent, but I understand that might be leveled at the larger conversation around AI use and perhaps doesn’t apply to what I’m up to here. I personally find myself asking “Why?” a lot, attaining new skills, and using my brain to problem solve (the problem you’re concerned about here existed before AI, just saying). It sounds like you might be asking yourself some of these very important questions, and I’m here for that!

@TechVampire I’m glad you asked, because this is exactly the kind of scrutiny these apps should get. When I say I check things on my own phone, I mean two things: I run every change and watch what it really does, and I read the code. I can read it, and I do. I’m not a professional security auditor, and I won’t pretend to be one, but I’m looking over what’s getting released (again, I understand a lot of people right now aren’t with AI – and frankly it shows).

I also care about this personally. My family uses these apps too, so their safety matters to me for real, not just as a principle. And FWIW, I think the risk of one of them exposing someone’s private information is low, for two reasons. Most of these apps are about as harmless as software gets: a chess game, an instrument tuner, a recipe book. There just isn’t much personal data in them to leak. And where an app does handle something sensitive, the critical part isn’t code I wrote. Messaging’s encryption is Signal’s own, which I built in rather than wrote, and the apps that deal with passwords or money work the same way. The bigger issue, if this is your concern, are the Android 12 security flaws inherent in the device – act accordingly.

Beyond that, everything is open source, so anyone can read it. About half the apps have no internet permission at all, and the rest only talk to what they exist for, like your own Nextcloud. None has ads, and I don’t add analytics or tracking. I scan every push for secrets, and I write each privacy policy from the code and the manifest, never from memory.

If you or anyone here can read the code, I’d be truly grateful, and I’ll fix whatever you find as quickly as I can!

6 Likes

Just browsed community apps out of curiosity you were not kidding, it’s like a marathon of apps by Wander. Like others said, this 2.0 will probably eliminate the need for the community apps page entirely, otherwise I would make suggestions.

With that said, there’s so many great ideas coming from Wander. The daily medication reminder, weather app with radar, a field kit, speedometer, whereabouts. I thought I would have to give up my meshtastic ways by leaving my smart phone behind but the Mesh app looks sick! I understand the hesitation with using AI to vibecode though, at least it sounds like they are looking through the code itself. I definitely have my pauses with AI, but it is pretty remarkable one person can create such a library of apps.

Maybe not the place @wander I live in a city where my car is parked in a different spot every time and worry I’ll forget where I left it. A simple app that could just geotag a location would be amazing (even if I’ll need to open that location in another app, like the maps or Heremaps app).

2 Likes

I tried to find a decent place to post my questions I hope this is a good spot :slight_smile:

Hi! I’m a newbie to sideloading and such, its easy enough with the Kompakt but I just want to make sure I’m doing this properly. So far I’ve only sideloaded from f-droid and aurora to make app updates easy.

-When I download an apk from Github or from this mudita community app page, do I need to regularly be checking for updates? If there is an update in the app will it automatically apply in my phone or do I need to uninstall the apk and reinstall it? What’s the easiest method for keeping my apps up to date?

-If I use the “download apk” button at the top of a community apps page will it give me the most recent version? What if it has the red words “X Changed” next to it? What does that mean??

@wander I want to try your apps but I just wanted to make sure I know how to properly do this first lol

excited to see what the new update brings for apps in November!!

3 Likes

Welcome, and thank you for asking before diving in! Updates don’t apply by themselves when you install an APK by hand. But you don’t need to uninstall anything: download the newer APK and open it, and it installs over the old one and keeps your data.

The easiest way to keep track is Obtainium. Point it at an app’s GitHub page and it tells you when there’s a new version and installs it for you. If you follow a lot of my apps, set its checks to run less often.

On the red “Changed” label: on my apps it almost always just means I’ve put out a newer version since the card was last refreshed. The download button always gives you the newest one. If you ever want a hand with a particular app, just ask.

2 Likes

Thank you so much this is very helpful!

2 Likes

Thanks for the idea, @spencersabo, and the kind words about Mesh. I’ve built it: Parked. One button marks where you left the car, using a single fresh location fix at that moment. It then shows how long ago and, on request, how far and in which direction (“180 m NE”). “Open in maps” hands the spot to whatever maps app you have (HERE WeGo, Organic Maps and so on). It has no internet permission and keeps nothing off your phone.

Tell me what’s missing.

3 Likes

Thank you for taking the time to answer my question. I admit I’m very relieved that you know code yourself and are checking over the apps, that makes me comfortable enough to keep using them. I think someone generating a program entirely from vibe code and being unable to double-check any of it themselves is a disaster waiting to happen.

Alas I cannot read code myself at this time, it’s a skill I’ve never picked up. However this conversation prompted me to get off my butt and do something about that. If I’m going to get into open source tech and express wariness for AI-created software, I should walk the walk and be able to sus out concerning code for myself. I’ve made an account on FreeCodeCamp and I intend to start on the lessons tomorrow. Wish me luck!

4 Likes

This is amazing! Just tested it out and it works perfectly, thanks a bunch you saved me from a future crisis

2 Likes

Thank you, @wander, for Parked (“okiba”)!

Would it be possible to make it work with @davidray’s CalmMaps?

1 Like

Thanks, I’m glad it’s useful! Parked hands the spot to your maps apps through the standard map link, so any app that handles those links shows up in the chooser when you press “Open in maps”. I don’t know whether CalmMaps registers for them. If you install it and it doesn’t appear, @davidray would be the one to ask, since it’s a one-line setting on the maps side. In the meantime, “Share” sends the coordinates as text that you can paste into any app.

2 Likes